Once upon a time I would have been using words like introverted, anxious, eccentric and I might have used other none clinical descriptors like MBTI to signify personality style differences - people would have described me as shy at times in my life or quiet. Other times maybe someone would have said I was a bit neurotic - nobody would have said Autism.
All these other words make sense to me, chalking it all up to ‘autism’ does not. And Being diagnosed as such (as an adult) did me more harm than good in the longer term. ASD is something that should denote a disabling set of traits (impairment of social communication, interaction and restricted/restricting behaviours or interests) not just hobbies, interests, the ability to retain focus, character and personality differences. Using ‘Autistic Traits’ to describe the intricacies of personality removes all the colour from a person. It flattens them.
To me neurodiversity is talking about something else but seems hooked on using Autism and ADHD as the mule to get them there at the expense of devaluing the experiences of those with significant impairments and medicalising those off us who are perhaps ‘odd balls’ or a bit ‘asocial’ but actually move through world quite well when viewed with a more objective framing.
Yes, I agree. There has been a problematic blurring of personality traits with autistic traits (which still don't necessarily mean somebody has autism). It's all about their intensity and impact on an individual's functioning, as you suggest. What that means exactly isn't easy to get agreement on, and it lacks the pseudo-certainty of pinning a label on someone. But that has to be the distinction. I think you're right about the flattening effect too on an individual's personality - indeed, this is even apparent in those who clearly are autistic. Their personalities can be flattened out through over-medication. Again, knowing where to draw the line appears to be our greatest difficulty. You make an important point on that confusing of neurodiversity (as envisaged by Singer) and the diagnoses in the DSM. They are different if overlapping categories but they are too often conflated as if they mean the same thing, even by clinicians.
Hi Dave I'm beginning to think we need a much more robust response to the ‘social construct’ argument. Our children with profound autism are seriously unwell. They are ignored and left to suffer because people want to believe that autism is ‘normal’. Our son (23) has just been awake all night again. We are at the end of our tether and there is no medical support. If we had a designation of profound autism, the world might take it seriously. There are many families like ours, expected to suffer in silence. It is a huge injustice.
Sorry to hear things are difficult Jane and I couldn't agree more on the injustice you describe. I'm in two minds on this issue. On the one hand, it is true - as you say - that the argument made by some critics of overdiagnosis can end up giving the impression that autism is made up. I don't think they mean that necessarily, and I think Timimi makes this point himself - though some make arguments reminiscent of the medics of the past who blamed autistic-traits on childhood trauma (usually code for parental abuse or neglect). Others though are critical because they recognise that not every autistic person is high functioning and that their higher needs are being crowded out as a consequence of diagnostic drift. Having said all that, I think there's a danger of suggesting with the word 'profound' that those who are so-called high functioning have a 'mild' autism - which suggests this latter group don't need significant support. Some don't but some really do, and the impact on their functioning can still be profound if in a very different way. I have members of my family at both ends of the spectrum and I know how very different these children are. Perhaps that's the point. We're talking about very different autisms.
I agree - experience varies so much and we need to identify the differences in an easy way - for planning, treatment, understanding etc The label profound autism has a definition that fits the bill. I know other people have major challenges but if you can speak, read, write, have relationships and even children of your own, we are in different ball parks. Completely. I think the higher functioning people need to recognise this. Our children need to be seen and acknowledged. At the moment, they are hidden.
I enjoyed the first part of Sami’s book very much, agreed with almost everything, then completely parted company from him in the second part. Like you, I think the arguments from economics miss some crucial points about the state and wider social/cultural meaning making problems. Although I’m very willing to learn more, I’m always a bit suspicious when the term ‘neoliberalism’ is drafted in as the singular explanation of, well…everything. Perhaps it’s my own ignorance, but it doesn’t seem like a well-defined term in this context. More of a stand-in for a set of fixed ideological and political beliefs.
Autism, in its profound form, is very definitely a real thing. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if we eventually identify quite a clear biomarker for the condition. I think this depends on two things.
The first is overcoming the damage done by the debunked vaccines theory. Vaccines don’t cause autism, but the most compelling theories I’ve read do seem to point to some interaction between genetics and novel environmental exposures. I want to be clear that I am not advocating the resurrection of ‘frigid mother’ theories or parental blame. My nephew is profoundly autistic and my sister was hit with that incredibly hurtful accusation when he was first diagnosed. It couldn’t be further from the truth.
The second is restricting research samples to the profoundly disabled, rather than including people with wildly differing presentations and difficulties who dilute the phenomenon under study. You mentioned that you have recently been diagnosed with autism yourself. Having read your critically acclaimed book and spoken with you on a panel at the BoI, I find it really hard to encompass the idea that you have the same condition as my nephew. He can’t read, or write, or speak. He has to wear adult diapers. I can’t identify a single trait that you share in common, anything that might indicate that you were just at opposite ends of a single spectrum representing a unified underlying condition. It’s like classing cows and zebras as the same thing because they’re both black and white. You’re both human beings, but there the similarities end.
This is not to say for a moment that you don’t struggle, or that you don’t have traits that form a recognisable pattern shared by other people, one that comes with its own set of personal difficulties and challenges. I’ve been told that I have those traits too! Just before I parted company from the mental health system my clinicians were very keen to send me for an autism assessment. It would have been the sixth diagnosis they’d given me, which I think speaks to how blurry diagnostic constructs actually are when applied to people with less severe presentations.
I sincerely want everyone to get the support and sympathy they need to thrive, and it says something about our society that so many people now believe they need to be diagnosed with an illness before they are worthy of that support. But it seems to me that making progress on understanding and helping people like my nephew really does depend on being more discerning about who is diagnosed with autism. Those of us who are not profoundly disabled really need to search for meaning outside the medical system. That’s what I started doing seven years ago when I disengaged from the mental health system, and I wish I could share with everyone how fantastically liberating and richly satisfying it has been to understand myself beyond diagnostic labels.
I don’t disagree with any of that, Carrie. Still not sure what the deal is with me, and rather stumbled across my diagnoses after a few ‘issues’. And you’re right of course. I have the same dual diagnosis as my son, and I see a lot of me in him, but he is also far more profoundly affected than I ever was. And we are totally different too. I fall into that potentially dodgy category - late diagnosis, masking, reading your life backwards via a diagnosis etc. And yet … I wasn’t borderline and I do think Singer was onto something too.
This is such a good article. My distinction on the autisms is those who can communicate with spoken language and those who cannot. If spoken language is unavailable one can start to identify the anatomical areas of the brain that are not functioning...and from there tease out the malfunctioning of the cellular activities therein. We do this for neurodegenerative diseases...we need now to do this for neurodevelopment diseases.
Dave, your provocative title asks a scientific question: *Is autism real?* But I'm not sure the article answers it.
You cite Sami Timimi, who challenges the scientific validity of psychiatric classifications, but respond largely with anecdotes about David Byrne, your son and yourself.
You write that autistic people are "qualitatively different" from non-autistic people. But autistic people are qualitatively different from one another. So are non-autistic people. What exactly is the biological distinction separating these two populations?
You also worry about overdiagnosis, while acknowledging your own recent diagnoses. How do you establish who has been appropriately diagnosed and who has not?
I am an immunologist, and increasingly, I find that science has gone on holiday in discussions about neurodiversity. We recognise patterns, give them names, and then start treating the names as explanations.
The characteristics are real. The difficulties are real. But that does not establish that our classifications represent distinct biological conditions.
Surely the scientific question is not simply *what do we call these people?* but *how did they become who they are?*
And, perhaps more importantly, what can we do to change their developmental trajectory?
I’m not sure we disagree necessarily, Kevin. I don’t claim to answer the question. Indeed I wrote an entire book not answering the question. I’m also trying to redress the balance a little even in my own coverage of this subject. The point of the anecdotal detour is to point out that despite there being what I describe as a needs explosion, and a genuine problem with various diagnoses, that doesn’t mean we should disregard decades of research into autism as a disorder (albeit disputed) or allow an understandable cynicism to undermine support for those who need it. ‘How did they become who they are?’ We could go into the whole biology, environment, etc debate but even that is arguably getting ahead of ourselves. Who are ‘they’? That’s the biggest problem we face. Is it one autism or several autisms? Is it something else entirely? How does it overlap with ADHD? Does that exist? What is the impact of social and cultural trends particularly on children’s behaviour and on attitudes to what is normal? Like I say, lots of unanswered questions.
Thanks, Dave. I think it's excellent that more people are engaging with these questions, and I suspect we agree on quite a lot.
My concern is that we need to be disciplined about which language game we are playing.
You mention a "needs explosion", a "genuine problem with various diagnoses" and "decades of research into autism as a disorder". But what exactly do we mean by each of these? An increase in diagnoses is not necessarily an increase in need. Decades of research involving people classified as autistic does not, in itself, establish that autism is a distinct biological condition.
And then there is the question of support. I agree entirely that we must not abandon people who need help. But that is a different language game. A label may be valuable for advocacy, recognition and access to services without necessarily providing a biological explanation.
You ask, "Who are they?" For me, there is no "they" to begin with. There is only the person in front of us. I want to understand how that person became who they are, what constrains them and what might help.
Even late diagnosis raises an interesting question. If someone is diagnosed with ADHD at 66, what independent evidence establishes that they had ADHD at six? We must be careful not to use today's label to explain yesterday's behaviour and then use that explanation to validate today's label.
I welcome the debate. But if we are asking scientific questions, we need scientific discipline: clear definitions, testable propositions and evidence. Otherwise we risk moving between biology, classification and social advocacy without noticing.
And perhaps that's why I keep suggesting that science needs to come back from holiday.
Once upon a time I would have been using words like introverted, anxious, eccentric and I might have used other none clinical descriptors like MBTI to signify personality style differences - people would have described me as shy at times in my life or quiet. Other times maybe someone would have said I was a bit neurotic - nobody would have said Autism.
All these other words make sense to me, chalking it all up to ‘autism’ does not. And Being diagnosed as such (as an adult) did me more harm than good in the longer term. ASD is something that should denote a disabling set of traits (impairment of social communication, interaction and restricted/restricting behaviours or interests) not just hobbies, interests, the ability to retain focus, character and personality differences. Using ‘Autistic Traits’ to describe the intricacies of personality removes all the colour from a person. It flattens them.
To me neurodiversity is talking about something else but seems hooked on using Autism and ADHD as the mule to get them there at the expense of devaluing the experiences of those with significant impairments and medicalising those off us who are perhaps ‘odd balls’ or a bit ‘asocial’ but actually move through world quite well when viewed with a more objective framing.
Yes, I agree. There has been a problematic blurring of personality traits with autistic traits (which still don't necessarily mean somebody has autism). It's all about their intensity and impact on an individual's functioning, as you suggest. What that means exactly isn't easy to get agreement on, and it lacks the pseudo-certainty of pinning a label on someone. But that has to be the distinction. I think you're right about the flattening effect too on an individual's personality - indeed, this is even apparent in those who clearly are autistic. Their personalities can be flattened out through over-medication. Again, knowing where to draw the line appears to be our greatest difficulty. You make an important point on that confusing of neurodiversity (as envisaged by Singer) and the diagnoses in the DSM. They are different if overlapping categories but they are too often conflated as if they mean the same thing, even by clinicians.
Hi Dave I'm beginning to think we need a much more robust response to the ‘social construct’ argument. Our children with profound autism are seriously unwell. They are ignored and left to suffer because people want to believe that autism is ‘normal’. Our son (23) has just been awake all night again. We are at the end of our tether and there is no medical support. If we had a designation of profound autism, the world might take it seriously. There are many families like ours, expected to suffer in silence. It is a huge injustice.
Sorry to hear things are difficult Jane and I couldn't agree more on the injustice you describe. I'm in two minds on this issue. On the one hand, it is true - as you say - that the argument made by some critics of overdiagnosis can end up giving the impression that autism is made up. I don't think they mean that necessarily, and I think Timimi makes this point himself - though some make arguments reminiscent of the medics of the past who blamed autistic-traits on childhood trauma (usually code for parental abuse or neglect). Others though are critical because they recognise that not every autistic person is high functioning and that their higher needs are being crowded out as a consequence of diagnostic drift. Having said all that, I think there's a danger of suggesting with the word 'profound' that those who are so-called high functioning have a 'mild' autism - which suggests this latter group don't need significant support. Some don't but some really do, and the impact on their functioning can still be profound if in a very different way. I have members of my family at both ends of the spectrum and I know how very different these children are. Perhaps that's the point. We're talking about very different autisms.
I agree - experience varies so much and we need to identify the differences in an easy way - for planning, treatment, understanding etc The label profound autism has a definition that fits the bill. I know other people have major challenges but if you can speak, read, write, have relationships and even children of your own, we are in different ball parks. Completely. I think the higher functioning people need to recognise this. Our children need to be seen and acknowledged. At the moment, they are hidden.
I enjoyed the first part of Sami’s book very much, agreed with almost everything, then completely parted company from him in the second part. Like you, I think the arguments from economics miss some crucial points about the state and wider social/cultural meaning making problems. Although I’m very willing to learn more, I’m always a bit suspicious when the term ‘neoliberalism’ is drafted in as the singular explanation of, well…everything. Perhaps it’s my own ignorance, but it doesn’t seem like a well-defined term in this context. More of a stand-in for a set of fixed ideological and political beliefs.
Autism, in its profound form, is very definitely a real thing. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if we eventually identify quite a clear biomarker for the condition. I think this depends on two things.
The first is overcoming the damage done by the debunked vaccines theory. Vaccines don’t cause autism, but the most compelling theories I’ve read do seem to point to some interaction between genetics and novel environmental exposures. I want to be clear that I am not advocating the resurrection of ‘frigid mother’ theories or parental blame. My nephew is profoundly autistic and my sister was hit with that incredibly hurtful accusation when he was first diagnosed. It couldn’t be further from the truth.
The second is restricting research samples to the profoundly disabled, rather than including people with wildly differing presentations and difficulties who dilute the phenomenon under study. You mentioned that you have recently been diagnosed with autism yourself. Having read your critically acclaimed book and spoken with you on a panel at the BoI, I find it really hard to encompass the idea that you have the same condition as my nephew. He can’t read, or write, or speak. He has to wear adult diapers. I can’t identify a single trait that you share in common, anything that might indicate that you were just at opposite ends of a single spectrum representing a unified underlying condition. It’s like classing cows and zebras as the same thing because they’re both black and white. You’re both human beings, but there the similarities end.
This is not to say for a moment that you don’t struggle, or that you don’t have traits that form a recognisable pattern shared by other people, one that comes with its own set of personal difficulties and challenges. I’ve been told that I have those traits too! Just before I parted company from the mental health system my clinicians were very keen to send me for an autism assessment. It would have been the sixth diagnosis they’d given me, which I think speaks to how blurry diagnostic constructs actually are when applied to people with less severe presentations.
I sincerely want everyone to get the support and sympathy they need to thrive, and it says something about our society that so many people now believe they need to be diagnosed with an illness before they are worthy of that support. But it seems to me that making progress on understanding and helping people like my nephew really does depend on being more discerning about who is diagnosed with autism. Those of us who are not profoundly disabled really need to search for meaning outside the medical system. That’s what I started doing seven years ago when I disengaged from the mental health system, and I wish I could share with everyone how fantastically liberating and richly satisfying it has been to understand myself beyond diagnostic labels.
I don’t disagree with any of that, Carrie. Still not sure what the deal is with me, and rather stumbled across my diagnoses after a few ‘issues’. And you’re right of course. I have the same dual diagnosis as my son, and I see a lot of me in him, but he is also far more profoundly affected than I ever was. And we are totally different too. I fall into that potentially dodgy category - late diagnosis, masking, reading your life backwards via a diagnosis etc. And yet … I wasn’t borderline and I do think Singer was onto something too.
This is such a good article. My distinction on the autisms is those who can communicate with spoken language and those who cannot. If spoken language is unavailable one can start to identify the anatomical areas of the brain that are not functioning...and from there tease out the malfunctioning of the cellular activities therein. We do this for neurodegenerative diseases...we need now to do this for neurodevelopment diseases.
Thanks Doreen, seems like a potentially promising approach.
Dave, your provocative title asks a scientific question: *Is autism real?* But I'm not sure the article answers it.
You cite Sami Timimi, who challenges the scientific validity of psychiatric classifications, but respond largely with anecdotes about David Byrne, your son and yourself.
You write that autistic people are "qualitatively different" from non-autistic people. But autistic people are qualitatively different from one another. So are non-autistic people. What exactly is the biological distinction separating these two populations?
You also worry about overdiagnosis, while acknowledging your own recent diagnoses. How do you establish who has been appropriately diagnosed and who has not?
I am an immunologist, and increasingly, I find that science has gone on holiday in discussions about neurodiversity. We recognise patterns, give them names, and then start treating the names as explanations.
The characteristics are real. The difficulties are real. But that does not establish that our classifications represent distinct biological conditions.
Surely the scientific question is not simply *what do we call these people?* but *how did they become who they are?*
And, perhaps more importantly, what can we do to change their developmental trajectory?
I’m not sure we disagree necessarily, Kevin. I don’t claim to answer the question. Indeed I wrote an entire book not answering the question. I’m also trying to redress the balance a little even in my own coverage of this subject. The point of the anecdotal detour is to point out that despite there being what I describe as a needs explosion, and a genuine problem with various diagnoses, that doesn’t mean we should disregard decades of research into autism as a disorder (albeit disputed) or allow an understandable cynicism to undermine support for those who need it. ‘How did they become who they are?’ We could go into the whole biology, environment, etc debate but even that is arguably getting ahead of ourselves. Who are ‘they’? That’s the biggest problem we face. Is it one autism or several autisms? Is it something else entirely? How does it overlap with ADHD? Does that exist? What is the impact of social and cultural trends particularly on children’s behaviour and on attitudes to what is normal? Like I say, lots of unanswered questions.
Thanks, Dave. I think it's excellent that more people are engaging with these questions, and I suspect we agree on quite a lot.
My concern is that we need to be disciplined about which language game we are playing.
You mention a "needs explosion", a "genuine problem with various diagnoses" and "decades of research into autism as a disorder". But what exactly do we mean by each of these? An increase in diagnoses is not necessarily an increase in need. Decades of research involving people classified as autistic does not, in itself, establish that autism is a distinct biological condition.
And then there is the question of support. I agree entirely that we must not abandon people who need help. But that is a different language game. A label may be valuable for advocacy, recognition and access to services without necessarily providing a biological explanation.
You ask, "Who are they?" For me, there is no "they" to begin with. There is only the person in front of us. I want to understand how that person became who they are, what constrains them and what might help.
Even late diagnosis raises an interesting question. If someone is diagnosed with ADHD at 66, what independent evidence establishes that they had ADHD at six? We must be careful not to use today's label to explain yesterday's behaviour and then use that explanation to validate today's label.
I welcome the debate. But if we are asking scientific questions, we need scientific discipline: clear definitions, testable propositions and evidence. Otherwise we risk moving between biology, classification and social advocacy without noticing.
And perhaps that's why I keep suggesting that science needs to come back from holiday.