I loved Talking Heads. Their music seemed to come from nowhere - A Road to Nowhere perhaps. I first encountered them as a rather nervy, self-conscious teen. Their iconic singer David Byrne was by all accounts, including his own, difficult to work with. The band split up soon after I got into them. What was it about this strange, yet compelling, frontman with the awkward mannerisms, jerky movements and darting eyes? Why did I love his strange songs that seemed to view the world as if he had just arrived from another planet? Why did he and his songs feel so detached? Why was I drawn to them? Why was I so obsessed? I listened to little else other than Bowie - the other David. He was similarly other worldly. But it was Byrne who I really identified with. Bowie was strange too and explored - literally - alien themes and characters. But Byrne wasn’t creating characters. He wasn’t putting on masks or trying on costumes. He was turning his own peculiar character into a performance.
While researching my book, The Crisis in the Classroom: How the special needs explosion is destroying education, I came across Sami Timimi’s fascinating Searching for Normal. In it, he explains how psychiatric diagnoses are - unlike diagnoses for physical ailments - not really diagnoses at all. They are, he argues - in the absence of any objective tests to confirm their existence - social constructs. And yet, I can only counter (however subjectively) as the father of a child diagnosed with ASD and ADHD, that I have long been struck by the reality of at least the first of those diagnoses. As a paediatrician put it recently at a debate I was participating in - sometimes ‘you just know’. They have a certain way of carrying themselves - alongside an aversion to the social, an obsessiveness over special interests, eyes that don’t know where to look. That sort of thing.
Greta Thunberg finds it hilarious that eco-doomsters like her slightly younger self are still trying to save the planet. Climate catastrophe is no longer her special interest. She has moved on. This is not so strange for a young woman with ASD (and it’s rather in keeping with today’s shallow leftism). In an old interview with the autistic-activist yet to become the ‘Free Palestine’ flotilla-leader, she described herself as ‘super focused’ on what was then her thing. While they couldn’t be further apart politically, Jordan Peterson (in another old clip this time from a lecture) is insightful on the subject of autism. He explains that while most of us are able to ‘compress the world’s complexity into something we can manage’, the autistic person struggles with such abstractions. Certainly, ‘they don’t like people and that’s because people don’t stay in their perceptual boxes’.
A single-minded pursuit of ever-changing special interests, a deep discomfort and awkwardness around people are well established autistic traits. So the well-founded doubts over some of these diagnoses raised by Timimi don’t necessarily mean it’s all in our heads. But there is still something persuasive about his case against the ideology of neurodiversity. ‘There has never been a generation of young people as pathologised as this current generation’ he says. Timimi blames the ‘cult of self-awareness’, the impact of increasing individuation, a reaching for off-the-peg identities and the disappearance of social solidarities. Parents lack the authority, and the time, their own parents had. They are unable to rely on the support of progressively ‘diminishing local community and extended family connections’. There is a ‘mystification’ of growing up with adults encouraged to defer to experts.
He talks about the impact of the mental health industry on individuals, and how therapies can ‘trap them in patient-hood’. But while he is right to identify both identarian left wing politics as a caricature of the real thing, and the crisis of legitimation afflicting our ruling elites; Timimi, in my view, places too much weight on the ‘marketisation and exploitation’ of the vulnerable. The characterisation of people in this diminished way is a consequence of the crisis of human agency; itself a product of the failure of political projects of the past to take humanity forward. By critiquing the blaming of individuals for their crises, he overlooks the importance of individuals regaining a sense of their own agency to push back against the enfeeblement he pins on corporates (while rather overlooking the role of the state).
Are psychiatric labels always disempowering? Yes, they lose their efficacy with over-use. But in itself, is a diagnosis of a disorder always a bad thing? I don’t think so. It can be helpful or clarifying at least some of the time for some people. But for Timimi, it is ‘the commercialisation and monetisation of emotional distress and behavioural difference’ that is the problem. The marketisation of our emotional lives is quite apparent, but this strikes me to be a symptom of, rather than the cause of, a wider cultural shift that has been taking place over a period of decades. Neverthess, I am persuaded by his take on a tendency to freeze what are dynamic mental states into diagnoses, and on the loss of meaning that results from trying to excise that which we find uncomfortable from our lives. Likewise, there is much to like in Timimi’s focus on the ‘social origins of many people’s mental distress’.
But sometimes we should pathologise. The problem is not that we do it. The problem is that we do it too much. He talks of a ‘war against emotions’ - an argument I make myself - but paradoxically we are also saturated in emotions. It’s not as if we are being urged to bottle things up. Quite the opposite. We’ve gone from being the nation of the stiff upper lip to a nation of the quivering lower lip. This, it seems to me, is a consequence of a process of withdrawal from the world and an accompanying valorisation of individuals’ fragility and vulnerability; when we should be - as Timimi says - ‘helping people get on with their lives’. We have created what he calls meta-emotions - obsessing over ‘the way we feel about how we feel’ - an industry that is doing us more harm than good.
He blames what he calls the Mental Health Industrial Complex for making us ‘suspicious of a range of emotional experiences’. Interestingly, he argues that the enthusiasm for early intervention in policy circles is all about banishing bad feelings in their infancy. He doesn’t dismiss the problems that young people present with clinically. They are ‘real, tangible, visceral, disabling’ and can result in great harm he readily admits. But Timimi is sceptical of the over-naming of these distressing experiences, arguing that ‘the fear that our pain will never change is enabled by labelling it as a sign of something wrong in you’. We might call it the reification (or thingification), of our ever-changing emotional lives, forever searching inside ourselves for something that remains out of reach.
‘What if the problem is that you believe the problem is in you?’ he asks one of his distressed young patients. Giving your distress a name can be a problem. So absorbed are this generation by a long list of names they apply to their inner struggles, they are consumed by them. They forget that they are not just their inner worlds. They are in the world too. But this world never seems to figure in accounts of their struggles - except in dubious claims about the supposed dangers of mobile phones and social media. Timimi is right to say it’s no coincidence that we have seen the ‘ballooning’ of mental health and so-called neurodiverse diagnoses just as the ‘Western world has been experiencing social and economic decay’. Though, for me, he underplays the significance of the cultural trends shaping our understanding of our predicament, by focusing too much on the secondary role of the socioeconomic.
It is in the cultural sphere that the neurodiversity phenomenon primarily resides, as Telegraph columnist Annabel Denham seems to recognise:
It’s one of those new age, suitably fuzzy terms which we don’t quite understand but have to pretend has always been a part of our lexicon – similar to “equity”, “intersectionality” or “microaggression”. Officially, though, it’s a spectrum of illnesses, from ADHD to dyspraxia, which must always be validated, never gainsaid, however generic the “symptoms” may appear.
And yet, as much as I agree with her I can’t help but urge caution. As Denham says, we’ve got to the point where enthusiasts for this sort of thing portray ‘any hint of scepticism as akin to supporting the Slaughter of the First Born’. But without the admittance of doubt, without an openness to other explanations, it can turn to cynicism. We can so easily get carried away and before we know where we are people who need support will no longer be able to get it. However sceptical I may be about many of the assertions made in relation to so-called neurodiversity - autism exists. (I’ll put ADHD to one side for now.) It may be, as Denham and I have both described it, rather fuzzy around the edges - and that is, deliberately or not, being exploited. But anybody with the condition, or with a child with the condition, knows how real it is.
Maybe we’ll come up with a new way of describing it in the future, but the autistic person is qualitatively different to other non-autistic people; and they are likely to experience the world not just differently, but in a way that can have a significant and detrimental impact on their lives. Ill-defined and poorly understood as it is, and no doubt overdue a corrective with regards diagnostic tightening, it is a well-established (if definitionally contested) condition. But I don’t blame the sceptics. It’s those who defend the indefensible, who take the explosion of need at face value; who pretend we’re all just more ‘aware’ when actually we’re more confused, who have brought us to this point.
Why are so many not only seeking diagnosis but getting one? Why don’t they see themselves as a product, as Timimi puts it, of the ‘relationships and context’ of which they are a part? Why do we insist on just labelling them when they could ‘draw on shared experiences, strengths and resources’? The ‘lived experience’ of people with autism, and that of their families, can also be a resource for some if it allows them to take control of their lives. While it isn’t enough to rely on our subjective experiences, and we should be wary of a tendency for this to colonise what should be objects of disinterested inquiry, in the absence of a scientific breakthrough what else are we to do? While I am on the side of the critics of the ‘neurodiversity’ orthodoxy, and welcome a long overdue (if over-heated) debate; I also worry that we could be delegitimising diagnoses (like autism) that are not in themselves illegitimate. Or else dismissing the genuine difficulties of those who may ‘have’ something else. But, like I say, I don’t blame the critics. I blame those who should have known better.
David Byrne, after decades of being famously odd, self-diagnosed as autistic. And was embraced by ‘the community’. Just before my book went to the printers, I was diagnosed with ADHD - and, more recently, with autism too. (I haven’t yet referred to it as AuDHD as is the fashion.) When I shared the news with those closest to me, one of them responded with what amounted to ‘And?’ - as if I were a teenager coming out to their parents who knew all along. Another said: ‘Everyone’s got autism now’. In other words, no-one has. Today, a diagnosis of ADHD or autism leaves you stranded between the answer you sought and the self-questioning it prompts. Were the assessments up to scratch? Did I somehow con myself and the clinicians into believing it? Was I hoping for a deeper connection with my dual-diagnosed son? Now I’ve got the report to prove it, can I start to get to grips with what’s been bothering me or am I just a part of the needs explosion? Was I drawn to Byrne (and the Heads) because we’re both autistic? I was assessed! Surely, that makes a difference?
Image by Dirk Haun



Once upon a time I would have been using words like introverted, anxious, eccentric and I might have used other none clinical descriptors like MBTI to signify personality style differences - people would have described me as shy at times in my life or quiet. Other times maybe someone would have said I was a bit neurotic - nobody would have said Autism.
All these other words make sense to me, chalking it all up to ‘autism’ does not. And Being diagnosed as such (as an adult) did me more harm than good in the longer term. ASD is something that should denote a disabling set of traits (impairment of social communication, interaction and restricted/restricting behaviours or interests) not just hobbies, interests, the ability to retain focus, character and personality differences. Using ‘Autistic Traits’ to describe the intricacies of personality removes all the colour from a person. It flattens them.
To me neurodiversity is talking about something else but seems hooked on using Autism and ADHD as the mule to get them there at the expense of devaluing the experiences of those with significant impairments and medicalising those off us who are perhaps ‘odd balls’ or a bit ‘asocial’ but actually move through world quite well when viewed with a more objective framing.
Hi Dave I'm beginning to think we need a much more robust response to the ‘social construct’ argument. Our children with profound autism are seriously unwell. They are ignored and left to suffer because people want to believe that autism is ‘normal’. Our son (23) has just been awake all night again. We are at the end of our tether and there is no medical support. If we had a designation of profound autism, the world might take it seriously. There are many families like ours, expected to suffer in silence. It is a huge injustice.